@ErinPeckham You've made an extremely compelling case for the inclusion of MW in Nationals.
To be clear, I have only one issue, and it has nothing to do the existence of MM/MW/OM/OW. My one and only concern is that when any skier can choose division, it leads to some weird dynamics. Specifically, what division a given skier chooses can significantly impact the results in all of the divisions that skier could have chosen.
Perhaps you and Jason already have some good ideas to address this! I personally have only thought of a few options, and I don't love any of them.
1) Get rid of these divisions at Nationals. I'm kinda OK with this, but as I said you've made a compelling case that these divisions add a great deal of value for a certain audience -- and arguably one of the most important audiences for the event.
2) Set a cutoff score (or average or whatever) and those who are above the line must compete in their "super-elite" division. Personally, I think this is the best option, but it's still not great because the threshold would be so arbitrary. Still, I'd rather have a set line rather than the winner of the age division is "the best who chose not to compete in the super-elite division."
3) "Overlay" the super-elites as special prizes. For example, give a giant medal and have a medal ceremony for the 5 best scores by a woman over 35 in any division. This kinda sounds good at first blush, but I don't think it actually works. The conditions could end up drastically different for different age groups, and it would be impractical for the all the top folks to hang around to the very end to see if they got a super-elite medal. Plus it wouldn't have the "feel" of a competition.
So here's hoping you have better ideas!
Of course, what I'd really want the solution to be is drop MW from Nationals and replace it with an entire tour that is all MW. That would be amazing competition and I would absolutely watch it.
But unfortunately, we can't just write a rule that says "now there will be Master Womens tour." A whole lot of people would have to put in a whole lot of work to make that happen. And it's unclear how any of them would get paid for their time.
So, yeah, someone do that please. 🙂 And email me the TWBC link!