@Wish,
I'm with you here. I'm not sure that I think of it as an s-turn as well. I think of it more as a precursor step to the gate turn-in. I came across this thread while trying to think of the 11-1 analogy in different ways as it still wasn't quite clicking the way I wanted it to. Something felt like it was missing from the way I was implementing it. However, after reading this thread it occurred to me that I had never made the connection that the 11 o'clock hip rotation was meant to keep outbound direction. That observation has helped somewhat in the past week. Looking back at past video, I seem to be able to clock my hips to 11 o'clock or more without maintaining outbound direction if that is all I think about, haha.
I believe in many respects the two "techniques" are synonymous in that they accomplish the same things with different lines of thinking. I'm still following the 11-1 analogy I learned from you in another thread; this actually looks like it might be the thread where that suggestion originated. However, I have found that trying to maintain a very slight edge-out is a good way for me to get my hips to 11 o'clock and maintain width before initiating the 1 o'clock hip-rotation/gate-shot.
What really interests me in this thread is learning if people think the edge out right before the gate shot is significant contributor to help get the ski pointed across course quickly before the boat loads the skier. My testing on the water currently indicates that it isn't, but most pros seem to do something analogous so I'm wondering if I'm missing something. However, it's totally possible they are doing it for different reasons entirely.
My "s-turn" technique is:
1) edge out briefly
2) release load (ski casts out slightly and I start slowly coming back into the course)
3) turn-in and go (hips go from 11-1)
I think this is consistent with what I'm seeing in the Mapple video above (which has the best perspective). He performs his 11-1 hip rotation at around 12.5 seconds in the video, which is slightly after he has already started going inbound at around 12.25 seconds. However, that's when things start to get real.
@lakeaustinskier ,
I think I might agree here, but I can't be sure yet, haha.