Hortons question is good wrt ability vs age based competition in the Nationals. If we did remove ability based so everything was clear wrt age divisions, would the M3 guys be happier? I don’t think any of us expect MM or OM/OW to disappear from Nationals so I assume we will continue to have the format of age and ability based.
As long as we have elite divisions, I think skiers should have the choice, period. No forcing up. One part of a recent proposal was that if you CHOSE to ski MM (not qualified), you stayed there for the rest of the ski year. Similar how you have to choose your division before Regionals and ski the same at Nationals. Personally I am happy to ski MM and stay there vs M3, but what if I want to ski one round as OM for fun? I don’t want to be forced to stay there.
I don’t think there is enough abuse of the current system, or a superior rules proposal that will lead to change (mostly the latter). I think the options for those that don’t like it are A) fly to Okee and heckle and/or B) propose change to the rules committee. I haven’t seen a proposal I would vote for over the current situation, and I have no better ideas. The sport is better off as we passionately challenge it and want it to improve, but part of me is just happy we have a rules committee/Nationals at all.