If you don't know what happened, go watch the video on the masters website Day 2 Semi Finals: 4:23:20
The facts are we don't know what really happened.
On the judging, I believe there is a tower right by 6 ball. Looking at how Freddie came into 6, having to throw his ski around the buoy, it would have been a difficult call to make even with the best view.
My understanding of the rules is that, in order for the calls to be reviewed, the judges must have disagreed. We know the boat called 6 and we assume the tower called 5 and 5. Since the video review was not available (Freddie not in the shot while turning the buoy), The initial score, majority 5 stands.
The hear say... some say that they believed judges were watching the video on screen instead of watching the skier live. I am not sure what the judges configuration at masters is, but I was told it was a one tower configuration. In his comment, Dano said the judge have a great view of 6 ball, however the tower location would not really be a normal position for judging. If someone can confirm it would help understand the call.
Some also say tower judges did not make a call until review. Again I believe judges have to make a call, then review if necessary. If judges were not sure whether Freddie went around 6 because they could not see it, the rule says the benefit of the doubt goes to the skier's favor. This suggest that the tower judges did see Freddie go inside 6 and stood by their initial call.
The tech: All this could most likely have been resolved with a good video of the action. I am sorry for the person holding the camera in the boat, however, we can see on the replay that they were filming ahead of Freddie before 6 ball, then behind Freddie after 6 ball... Taking boat video is an important job, and skiers at 39, 41 go very fast. I am not sure who was in the boat but they did not seem experienced enough for the job of tracking a skier at this level. I don't think they should have been put in this situation. There was also a comment on the video, that the judges can use any video available to make the call, which is not correct.
What was the right call? Only Freddie, the boat judge, the tower judges know. Or do they? Who had the best view of the action? Boat judge, tower judges? I guess we will never know. (but I think boat judge 🙂
Should Freddie be banned? It's complicated. The Masters LOC does not have any obligations to make an official statement to explain what happened. It seems Freddie may have been emotional about it (no sh$t, I would have). Some say Freddie remained polite. It seems the judge may have been intimidated. Who knows...
Apparently, the LOC at tournaments can ban anyone they want for no reason.
For the Freddie fans, it was a bit of a risk for the Masters (LOC) and Nautique (the money) to not make a pubic statement. The fans will wonder whether it is because they didn't have a good enough reason but they did it anyway. Maybe they don't give a crap. Maybe they think one less non Nautique skier in the mix. Maybe Freddie broke someone's nose and kicked them to the ground... (2nd degree, he did not) We will never know.
The 2023 US Masters of Waterskiing
It is happening, with the same Chief Officials. Will the towers and cameras be the same. Will there be more drama? People will watch, there will be a new Masters champion, and we will just have to move on and hopefully see Freddie be invited in 2024.
P.S. Actual still frame of Freddie not running around 6 ball -:) Happy Masters week-end everyone!