MS, I would stick with the headband. My experiences with my 2 ruptures was it was the initial blow that caused the rupture and the headband absorbs that blow without any problems. I've been skiing with a headband of one type or another for over 15 years without blowing out an ear drum. This is after having a blowout each year in the previous 2 years before the headbands. While I was healing up I used wax earplugs to keep the ear canal dry. These plugs were air and water tight but I was always concerned that in the event of a hard fall, that initial blow could hit the plugs, compacting the air in the ear canal and cause another rupture. My fear could be overblown but it sure seemed to be possible. Plus with the headband you get to have, what one of my buddies describes as a gay euro trash look while you're working behind the boat. Very stylish.