@Razorskier1 Great shots, and not at all what I was expecting to see from your description. Let me first say that I think we are splitting hairs at times. Secondly, what we attempt to do on the water, and what we end up actually doing are almost always 2 different things. I totally hear what you are saying, and I can see where it would be beneficial. I'm not discounting the approach at all. But I am claiming it is less than ideal.
If folks find that opening to the boat is putting them back, or causing their ass to drag, or anything of the like....they are doing it wrong. Square/open to the boat by itself is no magic bullet. It is just a requirement...
Onside cut: hips facing ski tip, shoulders partially open (at about 45 deg) sounds like a concerted effort to twist the spine, in my opinion. Bad for the back....and less than ideal for being balanced on the ski. From the transition outbound, anytime the hips/shoulders/core attempts to twist away from the boat (towards the shore), the outbound direction will be compromised: Twisting outbound moves the rope tension to the leading side of your body, which turns your body into a huge roll of toilet paper that tends to get "unwound" back to the inside. By keeping the line tension at least centered through your body on the transition/outbound movement, there is no "Torque" on your body....allowing you to simply ride the end of the line outbound. Even better is a slight transition of the tension to the trailing arm (soon to be reaching arm), during the outbound move. Not saying its easy...but is the most effective/efficient, with the least adverse loading on the body
Of course you will have to approach the two leans (onside vs offside) differently. But one thing I will say, from reading folks wording on this topic, is to be more conscious of the hips/core....instead of the shoulders. Letting your left shoulder come forward a little bit on the offside cut is one way to think about opening up a bit....but when we think in terms of "shoulder-centric" movements (shoulders as a frame of reference), often times we forget about the other body parts, and its easy for the hips/butt/ski to get left behind or lost in the movement. That's why I tend to use "hip-centric" language, to make sure I'm not only managing the hips, but also whats directly above them and below them. i.e., the hips are the center of the system, where the center of gravity is.
What I tend to see with people who have a hard time utilizing the concept of "square" or "open" to the boat is either one of two things:
1. They cannot translate the idea into movement, or they cannot comprehend it in the manner it was presented. Either way, that is a coaching error, not a skier error.
2. They feel they have properly executed the movement, but it wasn't effective, nor was it the best freakin' thing they've ever felt in their lives. Either way, once again it is a coaching error (or self-coaching error), not an actual failure of the basic concept of square/open as the ideal anatomical position for acceleration & line control.
No doubt, most people who are self or club taught, and haven't been to a great coach like Seth, Rini, Drew, Rossi, TWB, etc.. will drop their butt when squaring their shoulders.
Butt back = weight back (and static)
Weight back = high load, low acceleration (low angle)
Weight forward = low load, high acceleration (and dynamic)
The pros are mostly Open/Square to the boat because it works. Not because they've learned how to make a bad position work.
Be Dynamic!
MB