If just for skiing in Calmish water I’d take the sportster. Newer, all glass, skis great, and has PP. If you’re skiing the course PP (or zero off) is extremely helpful. Without it you’re relying on the driver and never really sure of your speed. Just .5mph can make a big diff. Upgrade to stargazer if it hasn’t already been done. HOWEVER, if you want to use the boat on lake winni in anything but perfect conditions I’d look for a direct drive crossover (is that what we call them?) with a decent wake. A malibu sun setter with the diamond hull has a pretty darn good wake. Also some years of sport nautique, and I’m sure MC has an equivalent. All skiable and also usable In less than perfect conditions on winni. If you go this route see if you can ski before you buy and try different line lengths.