This whole topic/issue stopped short of achieving a meaningful outcome. Did our concerns get communicated loudly? Were they heard? Did they result in changes? Yep to all three. Did we get far enough? Some say so and others do not.
IMHO, we did not. Here's where we stopped too short of the goal:
1) We are forcing normal competitive members to be subjected to the same training deemed sufficient for a youth coach.
2) The official policy language on who does BGCs does not adequately specify AWSA roles (despite NSSA having specific language about directors, etc.), and does not match what we were told.
What does the goal look like for me?
1) Members are provided with an awareness training option that is less than 30 minutes to complete. If USAWS insists on using SafeSport curriculum, then USAWS needs to respectfully demand that SafeSport produce and provide this content for these types of audiences for all NGBs.
2) The official USAWS policy language should state what we are told it means. Then, there is no need to "interpret" its application. Further, the slippery-slope text must be removed. If USAWS wants to expand the scope of BGCs, then it can follow the current process of involving division leadership, votes, etc. to make that change.
Regarding #1, Did USAWS even ask SafeSport for improved curriculum? Will they? What's the harm in asking? Having separate content for these very distinctly different audiences is not out of the ordinary and may even improve the quality of the program's safety. It shouldn't be a very hard sell. Tell them we need this by April 2022. Let's push this fast. Surely other NGBs and USOC sport divisions would support this, too.
Regarding #2, There should be no concerns from USAWS about making edits which correctly state what they told us. Right?!? Here are some edits which would align the actual text with what we were told was the intent.
https://www.teamusa.org/USA-Water-Ski/Safe-Sport/Background-Screening-FAQhttps://teamusa.org/USA-Water-Ski/Safe-Sport/Background-Screening-FAQ
Q: Who is required to complete the background screening?
A: USA Water Ski & Wake Sports requires criminal background screening (‘background screening’ or ‘background check’) for individuals involved with its programs as part of a greater effort to promote a safe environment for members. Background screening must be completed for all certified instructors/coaches, participants and staff of national/international teams, show ski team show directors and assistant directors, USA-WSWS judges that are 18 and older who are appointed or assigned to work National Championship (specifically AWSA Appointed Judges only) and/or IWWF sanctioned World or Confederation Championship events in their respective sports discipline, junior development coaches and leadership, and any volunteer, third-party vendor or contractor who are (a) in position of authority over or (b) in regular contact with athletes. In addition, background screening must also be completed for all staff members, USA-WSWS and Sport Discipline Board Members, and other members/individuals designated by USA-WSWS in its sole discretion.
That last clause is over-reaching, slippery slope.
https://www.teamusa.org/-/media/USA_Waterski/SafeSport-Docs/USAWSWSSafeSportHandbook.pdf#page=20
USA Water Ski and Wake Sports judges (who are 18 and older) who are selected and approved by USA Water Ski and Wake Sports or one of its Sports Disciplines to officiate at a National Championships event (Specifically Appointed Judges for AWSA), or IWWF World Championships or Multi-Sports event, e.g. World Games, or Pan American Confederation Titled Event, shall complete the Safe Sport training and background check as required by USA-Water Ski and Wake Sports. 1/22
https://www.teamusa.org/-/media/USA_Waterski/SafeSport-Docs/SafeSportComplianceChart.pdf (found at https://www.teamusa.org/USA-Water-Ski/Safe-Sport/Sanctioned-Event-Requirements)
Add an Asterisk to "BB/SS*" the AWSA column and row for Officials. Then in the left margin:
"Officials - Judges (selected and approved to officiate at a National Championships event*, or any IWWF World Championships or Multi Sports event (e.g. World Games), or Pan American Confederation Titled Event)
* AWSA Appointed Judges only"