@Horton, I love the analog Mitutoyo. A work of art. I also almost only use mechanical watches. Got to love them!
@ColeGiacopuzzi, compare apples to apples. Digital Mitutoyo are more precise, accurate and consistent than analog Mitutoyo, which are probably more consistent than a USD 20 digital caliper. But for sure USD 20 digital calipers are way more consistent than USD 20 analog calipers.
Analog calipers have advantages in some conditions, like high magnetic fields, or extreme temperatures.