I installed a PCM impeller for my GT-40 and got 4 seasons of good service. When I removed it there were no cracks, it was still soft and it is now living in my glove box as a spare. I noticed that my boat was running a bit warmer than usual so I had a look and found the PCM replacement I installed last season is looking pretty rough. Same lake, same water, no changes to use of boat, same storage procedure. So now I am thinking the impeller PCM is supplying is possibly not as good as the "older" ones. I had a simular experience when I used a generic replacement impeller. Pulling and inspecting is now going to happen annually.