I assisted a disabled skier that previously represented USAWS at Nationals, Worlds, & local events. He had been away from skiing for 15 years and now he's back. He asked me to help him find a boat. The owner of the boat that we looked at said the boat was a "9 out of 10" regarding condition. It was a 2010 Nautique 200 w/602 hours; fairly clean cosmetically although not cleaned up (detailed). I went to test drive the boat and everything checked out fine. Seller says he changed the oil every 25 hours vs the normal 50 hours. I paid him for the boat, pulled it back to GA. 2 or 3 days later, we took it to the lake and we were never able to get it off the trailer. It had hydro-locked with water in the pistons and we attempted to crank the engine, it sounded very bad. Boat went back to our shop (new owner is a mechanic), and he pulled the plugs - water shot out of all 8 pistons. He then pulled the exhaust manifolds, & risers; then machined the manifold surfaces to exact tolerances, cleaned rust & gunk from risers, replaced impeller, new gasket, flushed crankcase and removed more deposits, and then did a final oil change. Prior to flush & changing oil, engine was running and we pulled a hot oil sample from the dipstick with a sampling pump. New owner also noticed rust on the end of the dipstick which indicates this isn't the first time this has happened. See attached oil analysis. I called the co-owner and explained everything that we did in attempts to do a complete repair and went over the oil analysis results with him. I then asked that they provide some compensation due to the above issues. I am trying to give the seller the 'benefit of doubt' but suspicion has crept in. I am leaving the seller's name anonymous for now in the event that he chooses to do the right thing.
Poll Question - Should the seller provide some measure of compensation since this occurred the very first time we attempted to crank the boat?